From the Upper Delaware to Montana

How I got my start as a fly-fishing guide and ended up taking anglers around the world

My first guiding job on the Upper Delaware started with a fishing trip to Montana. I was a paying customer on that trip, which tells you how much of a career plan I had at the time.

I met Lee Hartman in the mid-1990s when I signed up for one of the fishing trips he ran out in Montana. We got to know each other on that trip, and after we got back East, Lee gave me my first guiding job on the Upper Delaware.

I’d spent plenty of time with a fly rod in my hand, but guiding made me look at a river differently. When I was fishing alone, I could make a few casts and move on whenever I felt like it. With a client, I had to think about where to put them, what kind of cast they could make from there, and how to talk them through a good drift. Lee started showing me the Delaware with all of that in mind.

The Twenty-Inch Rainbow

One day we were out on the river and nothing much was happening. I kept looking for a rise to give me somewhere to start. Lee handed me a White Wulff and had me fish the seams and riffles. I could pick out those white wings in the broken water and follow the fly as it drifted along the edge of the faster current.

Then the fly disappeared and a fish tore downstream.

I’d heard plenty about the big rainbows in the Upper Delaware, and as soon as that fish started taking line, I figured I had one. The longer I fought it, the bigger it got in my head. By the time I worked it close enough to see, I’d settled on twenty inches. I was probably being conservative.

It was a shad.

I’ll admit I was a little disappointed. I’d spent the better part of the fight looking forward to seeing that rainbow. Of course, if somebody had told me ten minutes earlier that I’d get a fish to eat a dry fly and take me downstream, I’d have been happy to take the deal.

The White Wulff earned a spot in my Delaware fly box that day. And the next time I stood there waiting for a rise, I knew I could give the seam right in front of me a few drifts.

Two Young Bucks and an Old Barn

After a stint guiding for Lee, I went out on my own as a freelance Delaware River guide. That’s when I met Ken Tutalo, my brother from another mother. We were two young bucks trying to make a living on the Upper Delaware. Ken owned Baxter House River Outfitters, and I did a lot of overflow guiding for him and his clients.

We had a great time exploring the river together. I like to say we learned from each other, and we did. If we were keeping score, though, I’d have to give Ken a comfortable lead. He knew the river system, especially the East Branch, where I had hardly any experience. I was lucky to have a friend willing to spend time on that water with me and share what he knew.

Ken had remodeled an old barn into his fly shop. When we weren’t on the river, there was a good chance we were hanging around that barn. We were even graced by the presence of Ralph Graves. We’d sit around tying flies and enjoying each other’s company. Between taking clients out, exploring the river, and spending time in that shop, we were living the dream.

I still remember Ralph’s infamous line. I’d hand him a fly I’d just tied, feeling pretty pleased with myself. He’d look it over and say, “That will catch a fish.”

I learned to translate. What Ralph meant was, Try again. That fly was shite.

Over the years I made some great friends on the Upper Delaware. Between guiding and fishing it on my own, I spent enough time on the system to begin to understand the fishing and the fish. Begin is the word I’d use even now. The Delaware is a tough river to learn. You can fish a stretch often enough to have a favorite place to stand, then spend an afternoon wondering why you ever thought you had the place figured out. Those were usually the days I had the most to talk about when I got back to the shop.

Evenings at the Slide Inn

Every summer I took what I’d learned on the Delaware out to Montana, where I guided on the Madison, the Yellowstone, the Jefferson, and other rivers and streams. I’d first gone west as a client on one of Lee’s trips. Now I was the one taking people fishing, and Montana was where I really stepped up my game.

That’s where I was lucky enough to meet Kelly Galloup. Kelly owned the Slide Inn fly shop, and just about every evening I’d wander in to pick his brain. After a day of being the guy who was supposed to have the answers, I usually had a few questions of my own.

Kelly was, and still is, the real deal. A few times I got to fish with him and try my luck with those pesky rainbows just upstream of the shop. Fishing with Kelly gave me a chance to see how he put all that advice to work. Those evenings at the Slide Inn and those few outings with Kelly paid off when I went back to work with clients.

The Trips That Opened the World

These days, I wander the globe looking for new places to take the people who trust me with their fishing trips. When I visit a lodge or spend a day on the water with an outfitter, I’m already thinking about which of my clients would love it there. So much of that part of my life goes back to my good friend Barry Serviente.

I worked for Barry for many years as his assistant at the fly-fishing shows. Every year, as a bonus, he’d take me on a fishing trip. I always looked forward to those trips. I got to fish some wonderful places, and along the way I met people who ran some of the best lodges and outfitting operations in the world. Those relationships made it possible for me to start bringing clients on trips of my own.

I wish I could sit down with Barry today and tell him where some of those trips have led. I’d tell him about the places I’ve gone back to, the people I’ve been able to take with me, and the places I’m still itching to see. Then I’d thank him again for taking me along in the first place.

There’s still a White Wulff in my Delaware box. It makes me think of Lee showing me where to cast, Ken and Ralph at the tying bench, Kelly at the Slide Inn, and Barry taking me along on another trip. It also makes me think of that twenty-inch rainbow. For most of the fight, it was a hell of a fish.

I still get excited when I spread out a map and start looking at water I’ve never fished. Before long I’m thinking about who I’d like to take with me and what we might find when we get there. After all these years, that’s still one of my favorite ways to spend an evening.

The future is bright, and as far as I’m concerned, I’m just getting started.

The Wandering Sportsman
Where the Journey Matters as Much as the Catch, the Flush, or the Harvest.

The people who helped me find my feet as a fly-fishing guide, from the Upper Delaware to Montana.

Next
Next

What Maine Taught Phinnigan